Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts

Saturday, March 22, 2014

Yet Another Firm Step to De-criminalise Indian Politics

Dr. A Surya Prakash, 
Distinguished Fellow, VIF

The Supreme Court took yet another firm step recently to cleanse politics and to de-criminalise the country’s legislative bodies when it directed trial courts hearing cases concerning corruption and serious offences against MPs and legislators in the states to complete the trial within one year of framing of charges. In an interim order, the Bench of Justices R.M.Lodha and Kurian Joseph said where sitting legislators are facing corruption cases and other serious offences, “the trial will be completed expeditiously on a day-to-day basis and in no instance later than one year from the date of framing of charges”.

This is the second major directive from the apex court after its path-breaking verdict in July, 2013 ordering disqualification of all MPs and MLAs soon after their conviction in heinous cases. Through this judgement, the court stopped MPs and MLAs from merrily continuing in office after filing an appeal against the lower court’s order as provided for in Section 8 (4) of the Representation of the People Act. The court struck down this provision in the RP Act, which had been grossly misused by elected representatives with criminal backgrounds. Exploiting the justice system which is painfully slow, legislators convicted of crimes like murder, rape and dacoity were known to complete their terms in Parliament and state legislatures, return to these legislative bodies when fresh elections were held and even hold key portfolios in the government at the Centre and in the states. All they had to do was to file a criminal appeal in a High Court within the stipulated time and the cases would drag on for 10 or even 15 years.

The mischief lay in Section 8(4) and this remained on the statute book for decades despite strong and persistent recommendations from the Law Commission of India, The Election Commission and a host of other commissions and committees including the National Commission Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC), which was headed by the former Chief Justice of India Mr.M.N.Venkatachalaiah. But the political class failed to heed to the suggestions and proposals for scrapping Section 8(4) because almost all political parties had legislators with criminal backgrounds and they did not want them to be unseated. Secondly, since criminal cases dragged on endlessly and the rich and powerful found a dozen ways to stall the trial in such cases, criminals roamed around the corridors of power and Parliament with impunity.

The Supreme Court struck the first major blow against criminal-legislators when it declared that Section 8 (4) was illegal. It said henceforth, upon conviction legislators would lose their seats. Lalu Prasad Yadav became the first politician to be hit by this ruling. He lost his seat in Parliament after this judgement although the Manmohan Singh Government was all set to bring in an ordinance to nullify the court’s verdict.

The latest order of the court directing that the trial in cases involving MPs and MLAs be completed within one year will have an impact on many persons with such background who are likely to contest and succeed in the coming Lok Sabha election. Although the distribution of tickets is still on, one can already see that a large number of persons with criminal records have been given tickets by many political parties including the Congress, the BJP, the Samajwadi Party and the Bahujan Samaj Party. The trial courts are now mandated to complete the trials within one year. Therefore, all persons who stand accused of heinous crimes and who get elected to the new Lok Sabha will not have the luxury of seeing prolonged trials. Secondly, if they are pronounced guilty, they will immediately forfeit their seats in view of the Supreme Court’s Verdict last year.

One only needs to analyse the affidavits filed by candidates before the Election Commission at the time of filing nominations for elections to understand the extent to which our democratic bodies have become dens of criminals and the corrupt. Following the Supreme Court Judgement of July, 2013, the Association of Democratic Rights (ADR) and National Election Watch (NEW) conducted an analysis and came up with some shocking statistics. They said as per the affidavits filed by them, as many as 1460 of the 4807 sitting MPs and MLAs in the country (30 per cent) had declared that there were criminal cases against them. Of them, as many as 688 (14%) out of the total number of sitting MPs and MLAs had declared serious criminal cases against themselves. Further, ADR has found that 162 of the 543 MPs of the outgoing Lok Sabha (30 per cent ) had declared criminal cases against themselves of which 14 per cent of the MPs have declared serious criminal cases against themselves. Of the 4032 MLAs in the country, as many as 1258 (31%) from all state assemblies had declared criminal cases against themselves. Here too, 15 per cent of the MLAs from all state assemblies said that they faced serious criminal cases against themselves, according to this analysis by ADR.

Following the latest Supreme Court order directing speedy trial of such cases, ADR and NEW reported that the 162 MPs were involved in 306 criminal cases and that 76 of them stood charged with serious crimes like murder, attempt to murder and kidnapping. However, all these MPs were completing their Lok Sabha terms without hindrance because the cases were pending in court. These organisations said that some of these cases were pending for over 20 years. On an average, the pendency was for about seven years. They found a case of murder in which a member of the present Lok Sabha is an accused, dragging on for close to three decades while another murder case against an MP in Uttar Pradesh was in “progress” for 25 years. One case against an MP facing the charge of rioting and theft was on for 28 years. Providing a party-wise break up, the two organizations said that Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) MPs had 69 criminal cases against them followed by the BJP (55 cases), the Samajwadi Party (34 cases) and the Congress (30 cases). One MP belonging to JMM from Palamau, Jharkhand had declared 69 counts of serious cases against himself.

The court’s order last week came in the light of this frightening statistical analysis and the recent report of the Law Commission on Electoral Disqualifications. The Commission’s report on this issue was consequent to a direction by the Supreme Court last December. In this report, which was finalized last month, the Law Commission said that disqualification upon conviction had “proved to be incapable of curbing the growing criminalisation of politics, owing to long delays in trials and rare convictions. The law needs to evolve to pose an effective deterrence and to prevent subversion of the process of justice”. It therefore favoured disqualification of MPs and MLAs at the stage of framing of charges by the trial court. It said the stage of framing of charges “was based on adequate levels of judicial scrutiny, and disqualification at the stage of charging, if accompanied by substantial attendant legal safeguards to prevent misuse, has significant potential in curbing the spread of criminalisation of politics”.

Further, once the charges were framed and the legislators were disqualified, the Commission felt that the trial must be speeded up. It said for charges framed against sitting MPs and MLAs, the trials must be expedited so that they are conducted on a day-to-day basis and concluded within a one year period. It is of the view that if the trial is not completed within a year, the tainted legislator would stand automatically disqualified. Alternately, the rights, remuneration and perks of the MP or MLA could be suspended. The Commission also proposed some safeguards to prevent persons in power from filing false charges against political opponents in the run up to en election to the state assembly or parliament. It has also recommended enhanced punishment of two years in jail for persons who give false affidavits while filing nominations in an election.

This recommendation of the Law Commission must be seen in the light of the opinion of several other commissions and committees. For example, the Election Commission recommended 17 years ago that conviction by a trial court was sufficient to attract disqualification “and even those released on bail during the pendency of their appeals against their convictions are disqualified from contesting elections”. The NCRWC recommended that the election law be amended to bar any person charged with an offence punishable with imprisonment up to five years, from contesting elections to parliament and state assemblies. Further, it said any person convicted for heinous offences like murder, rape, dacoity and smuggling must be permanently barred from contesting elections. The Second Administrative Reforms Commission headed by Mr Veerappa Moily, a member of the Union Cabinet, recommended that Section 8 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 be amended “to disqualify all persons facing charges related to grave and heinous offences and corruption”, with the modification suggested by the Election Commission.

However, none of this had any effect on the political executive and the UPA Government made a futile bid through Law Minister Kapil Sibal last year to up turn the Supreme Court judgement which said convicted MPs and MLAs would stand disqualified even if they appealed against their convictions. The Manmohan Singh Government assured all political parties that it would amend the RPA Act, 1951 to help criminal politicians, some of whom were keeping the government alive through their support in the Lok Sabha. Sibal, who piloted this obnoxious piece of legislation even felt emboldened to advice the judiciary that it should be “extremely careful” while giving rulings because there was a negative perception in the country that all politicians were criminals and that the courts were enthusiastic to prove this to be right. Sibal also made the laughable claim that the political class was the most accountable class in the country and that the politicians were accountable to parliament, to the Election Commission, to the country and to the people.


Fortunately, no one is listening to Sibal’s rant against judges and on behalf of criminal politicians, least of all the judiciary. The Supreme Court, in its interim order last week on the PIL filed by Public Interest Foundation has partly accepted the suggestion of the Law Commission and ordered expeditious trial of cases pending against MPs and MLAs. Last year the court declared that legislators would stand disqualified once they are convicted by a court in a serious criminal case. The Law Commission is now suggesting that the disqualification should kick in the moment the trial court frames charges. We must now await the court’s final judgement in this PIL and hope that it will finally purge our legislatures of criminals.

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

The Right to Reject: A Major Step Towards Cleansing Public Life

Dr. A Surya Prakash, 
Distinguished Fellow, VIF

Voters in the five states going to polls this November-December viz Madhya Pradesh, Chattisgarh, Rajasthan, Delhi and Mizoram, will, for the first time have the right to press the NOTA (None Of The Above) button on their voting machines if they are disappointed with all the candidates in the fray in their constituencies.

The Election Commission has announced that it will provide voters the NOTA option following the recent Supreme Court verdict on the issue. This will constitute a major improvement on the situation that prevailed prior to the apex court verdict. Earlier, voters had the right not to vote after registering their presence in a polling booth. However, under the Conduct of Election Rules, their decision would be recorded in a register. Thus, the election law did not ensure secrecy for the voter who preferred not to vote. The apex court’s verdict will now ensure secrecy. Candidates and political parties will not know who all pressed the NOTA button in the voting machines. The court has hoped that this will have a salutary effect on the process of selection of candidates by political parties.

This judgement of the Supreme Court has been welcomed by electors and opinion makers across the country. Coming as it does in the wake of the court’s historic judgement last July to bar criminals from entering legislative chambers, this judgement is seen as yet another major step towards cleansing public life in the country.

In its judgement, the three-judge bench headed by the Chief Justice Mr. P.Sathasivam said that giving the voter the right not to vote for any candidate while protecting his right of secrecy was “extremely important”. When voters got the right to reject, it would bring about “systemic change”, force political parties to field persons of integrity in elections and foster the purity of the electoral process. It said the absence of the right to cast the negative vote would defeat the freedom of expression and right to liberty. The judgement comes in the wake of a sustained campaign by citizens’ groups for the NOTA option in ballot papers and voting machines. The court has directed the Election Commission to make necessary changes in the Electronic Voting Machines and ballot papers to give voters the power to stamp NOTA.

The timing of this judgement could not have been better. Despite mounting criticism of the quality of persons chosen by political parties to contest elections, parties seemed unwilling to clean up their act. The only criteria adopted by political parties for dispensing tickets is “winnability”, meaning that only those with money power and muscle power stood a chance of securing a ticket.

While every political party must take the blame for choosing less-desirable persons as candidates and for the growing frustration among people regarding the democratic system, the ruling United Progressive Alliance government at the Centre must take the blame for behaving in the most irresponsible manner in this regard. The Supreme Court decided last July to strike down Section 8 (4) of the Representation of People (RP) Act, 1951 which enabled criminals to continue their tenures in Parliament and state assemblies if they filed appeals against their conviction in a higher court. Though the court did not bar politicians who are charge-sheeted from contesting polls, it declared that a person convicted and sentenced in heinous cases, should be kept out of legislature, even if his appeal is pending in a higher court. The court also barred persons in jail from contesting elections because such persons lose the right to vote. We all know the desperate measures the Union Government took to try and protect criminal-politicians, including introduction of bills in Parliament and drafting an ordinance thereafter. When these decisions caused public revulsion, the government backtracked.

The court’s order also comes in the wake of valuable research data put out by the Association of Democratic Rights (ADR) and National Election Watch on the quality of persons who enter our legislative bodies. These organizations found that as many as 30 per cent of the sitting MPs and MLAs in the country (1460 out of 4807 MPs and MLAs) had criminal cases against them. Out of them, as many as 688 (14%) sitting MPs and MLAs have declared serious criminal cases against themselves. One realizes the value of Supreme Court’s judgements when one sees these figures, which would put politicial leaders in most countries, except India, to shame. Since one-third of the elected representatives have criminal records, it is only fair that voters have the right to reject and that is what the court has granted them in the latest order.

The Election Commission is already considering alterations to the EVMs to provide for a paper trail that gives proof of voting to every voter. This demand came about because of allegations that EVMs could be rigged. In any case the commission should be happy with the apex court’s judgement because the Commission had itself proposed NOTA way back in 2001 and reiterated it in the Chief Election Commissioner Mr.T.S.Krishna Murthy’s recommendation to the Prime Minister in 2004. In that letter, the CEC said “Although, Rule 49-O of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 provides that an elector may refuse to vote after he has been identified and necessary entries made in the Register of Electors and the marked copy of the electoral roll, the secrecy of voting is not protected here inasmuch as the polling officials and the polling agents in the polling station get to know about the decision of such a voter”. He therefore recommended that the Conduct of Election Rules be Amended. The government however did not act on this recommendation, prompting this direction from the Supreme Court.

The NOTA right is basically the right to cast a negative vote. However, this is not the complete solution, because even if a majority of the voters press this button, the election process will not be void. The Election Commission will count the remaining votes cast and declare the candidate who got the highest votes as the winner. Therefore, a bigger battle may lie ahead in order to find the ultimate solution to the problem posed by the quality of persons entering the electoral fray.


Long years ago, the former Vice-President Mr.Krishan Kant had demanded that such a provision be made in the ballot paper to enable electors to exercise their right to reject candidates in an election. The Law Commission too had supported this proposal. But the political system has become so corrupt and immoral that it refuses to consider anything other than “winnability”. It has been dismissive of all such proposals which aim to cleanse the political process as impractical or as proposals coming from individuals who are disconnected from the reality of electoral politics. The citizens have no option but to knock on the doors of the Supreme Court and the apex court, which is aware of the deteriorating environment, has stepped in to protect the right of citizens to better representation in democratic bodies.  

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

The Case Against The Ordinance to Protect Criminal Legislators

Dr. A Surya Prakash, 
Distinguished Fellow, VIF

The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC) which was headed by the eminent jurist and former Chief Justice of India Mr. M. N. Venkatachalaiah recommended that the election law be amended to bar any person charged with an offence punishable with imprisonment up to five years, from contesting elections to parliament and state assemblies. Further, it said any person convicted for heinous offences like murder, rape, dacoity and smuggling must be permanently barred from contesting elections.

The Second Administrative Reforms Commission headed by Mr.Veerappa Moily, a member of the Union Cabinet, recommended that Section 8 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 be amended “to disqualify all persons facing charges related to grave and heinous offences and corruption”, with the modification suggested by the Election Commission. The Law Commission suggested 14 years ago that mere framing of charges by a court in regard to election-related offences should by itself be a ground for disqualifying a person from contesting an election. In other words, all the three august commissions named above held the view that mere framing of charges was enough to bar individuals from contesting elections to parliament and state assemblies.

The Election Commission decided 16 years ago that candidates in parliament and state assembly elections should file affidavits about their convictions in cases covered by Section 8 of the RP Act, 1951. The commission was of the view that conviction by a trial court was sufficient to attract disqualification “and even those released on bail during the pendency of their appeals against their convictions are disqualified from contesting elections”.

Thereafter, in September, 1997, the Chief Election Commissioner wrote to the Prime Minister in this regard and pressed for immediate amendment of the law to deal effectively with the malaise. He said there were “grave incongruities” in the existing provisions in Section 8 and wanted the same amended. The Commission said that under jurisprudence, a person is presumed to be innocent unless proved otherwise and convicted by a court of law. Thus, in strict legal parlance, a criminal is one who has been convicted of a crime by a court of law. “But the common man perceives otherwise. In his eyes, a person who has been charged with certain types of offences and is under trial is also a criminal. The common man considers it criminalization of politics if he sees a history-sheeter or a notorious bad character, involved in various crimes of a heinous nature like murder, dacoity or rape, contesting elections and getting elected”.

It held the view that “a person facing trial in a serious offence, if kept out of the electoral fray till he is exonerated of the charge, should not have a legitimate grievance, as such restriction on his right to contest elections would be a reasonable restriction in the greater public interest and for bringing sanctity to the august Houses which are the supreme law making bodies of the country”. The Election Commission’s efforts to keep criminals out of electoral politics were stonewalled by successive governments at the Centre for 16 years.

It is in this context that the Supreme Court decided last July to strike down Section 8 (4) of the RP Act, 1951 which enabled criminals to continue their tenures in Parliament and state assemblies if they filed appeals against their conviction in a higher court. Any judge in any democracy who sees steady deterioration in democratic values is bound to correct the aberration. And that is exactly what the Supreme Court did last July. Though the court did not bar politicians who are charge-sheeted from contesting polls, it declared that a person convicted and sentenced to two years’ imprisonment, should be kept out of the electoral fray, even if his appeal is pending in a higher court. The court also barred persons in jail from contesting elections because such persons lose the right to vote.

The Union Cabinet’s first response to the Supreme Court verdict was to amend the Representation of the People Act, 1951 in order to save the seats of criminal legislators. At its meeting on August 22, it approved two amending bills to negate the recent Supreme Court verdict on disqualification of convicted legislators. The first amendment sought to add a proviso to sub-section (4) of section 8 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 stating that the convicted member shall continue to take part in proceedings of Parliament or Legislature of a state but he or she shall neither be entitled to vote nor draw salary and allowances till the appeal or revision is finally decided by the court. The other amendment said an MP or MLA would not lose his right to vote if under arrest even for a short duration and thereby would retain his right to contest a poll. However, despite the government’s desperate efforts during the Monsoon Session of parliament, it could not effect these changes because a key amending bill was referred to a parliamentary standing committee.

The latest decision of the Union Cabinet to bring an ordinance to undo the Supreme Court’s historic verdict in this case betrays its utter contempt for the opinions of some of the best legal minds in the country. Rejecting the sage counsel of eminent jurists, the political class has almost unanimously decided to challenge the Supreme Court’s verdict and to take legislative measures to undo parts of the apex court’s order. Sailing along with this view, which was expressed forcefully by politicians from across the political spectrum at an all-party meeting convened prior to the Monsoon Session of Parliament, the government announced its resolve to seek a review of the apex court’s judgement and simultaneously introduced a Bill to amend the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The purpose of this amendment is to protect the so-called rights of criminal-politicians rather than that of the people. They are also meant to overturn the verdict of the Supreme Court relating to the prohibition on persons in jail losing their right to file nominations in elections. The Rajya Sabha cleared this amendment first. The Law Minister Mr.Kapil Sibal, who piloted this Bill decided to utilize the opportunity to lecture the judiciary and all and sundry. He advised the judiciary to be “extremely careful” in giving rulings which have an impact on the polity. He claimed that there was a negative perception in the country that all politicians were criminals and that the courts were enthusiastic to prove this to be right.

Only a few political parties have had the gumption to oppose this atrocious move to protect criminal-politicians. Among them are the two main communist parties. The Communist Party of India opposed the ordinance which enables convicted MPs and MLAs to continue in their posts if they have filed appeals against their conviction. It said the government had introduced a Bill to this effect in Parliament during the Monsoon Session and the same had been referred to a parliamentary standing committee. Under these circumstances, the CPI said the government should not be in a hurry to insulate convicted MPs and MLAs from disqualification as per the Supreme Court’s judgement. Opposing the ordinance, it said this matter needed to be discussed in parliament after the standing committee presented its report. The Communist Party of India (Marxist) also opposed the ordinance. It declared that the ordinance route was “undemocratic”. The Bharatiya Janata Party sent a delegation to the President urging him not to sign the ordinance.

Thanks to the Supreme Court’s directive many years ago, we have enough information on the criminal background of our legislators. So, let us test the actions of the union government and the Law Minister’s defence of the politician on the basis of available facts and the analysis of the background of our representatives done by the Association of Democratic Rights (ADR). This organization has found that 1460 of the 4807 sitting MPs and MLAs in the country (constituting 30 per cent) have declared criminal cases against themselves in their self- sworn affidavits submitted to the Election Commission of India prior to contesting elections. 688 (14%) out of the total number of sitting MPs and MLAs have declared serious criminal cases against themselves. Further, ADR has found that 162 of the 543 Lok Sabha MPs (30 per cent) have declared criminal cases against themselves. 14 per cent of the current Lok Sabha MPs have declared serious criminal cases against themselves. Of the 4032 MLAs in the country, as many as 1258 (31%) from all state assemblies have declared criminal cases against themselves. 15 per cent of the current MLAs from all state assemblies have declared serious criminal cases against themselves, according to this analysis by ADR.

Mr.Sibal also made the extraordinary claim that the political class was the most accountable class in the country and that the politicians were accountable to parliament, to the election commission, to the country and to the people, to whom they go every five years. It was strange to hear this from the Law Minister of a government that wants the Supreme Court to review its decision to bar convicted persons from continuing in parliament and state assemblies and which has decided desperately to take the ordinance route to overturn the Supreme Court verdict. It is equally strange to hear this from a Law Minister whose actions betray utter contempt for the opinions of the Law Commission, the Justice Venkatachalaiah Commission, the Second Administrative Reforms Commission, the Election Commission and the Supreme Court.


But the strangest development of all is the manner in which Mr.Rahul Gandhi, the Congress Vice-President who virtually slept through all the governmental moves since mid-July to bail out criminal-politicians, suddenly woke up last week and publicly rebuked his own government for bringing the ordinance. Realising belatedly that the government’s move had created much revulsion among the people and that even the President, Mr.Pranab Mukherjee was reluctant to sign on the dotted line, Mr.Gandhi has tried to salvage his own image at the cost of the Prime Minister and members of the Union Cabinet. But this will not wash. Intemperate conduct before cameras will not explain his deafening silence on this issue for 45 days. This is yet another example of what political power does to individuals. They think they have the power to fool all the people all the time.

Friday, July 5, 2013

Transparency: An Anathema to Indian Political Parties?

Dr. A Surya Prakash, 
Distinguished Fellow, VIF 

The strong and adverse reaction of national political parties to the recent order of the Central Information Commission (CIC) bringing them within the purview of the Right to Information Act (RTI) has provided proof, if proof was needed, that most of them are averse to transparency and accountability in regard to collection of funds, allotment of party tickets and such other intra-party issues. But the biggest disappointment is that the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the two Communist parties are sailing along with the Congress Party which is currently reeling under a series of scams.

Sadly, the Congress Party, which is the country’s oldest political party, is leading the charge against the CIC. It has dubbed the CIC’s order as “adventurist” and even claimed, by some strange logic, that the order demanding transparency in the working of political parties would “harm democratic institutions” because it would encroach upon the “privacy” of political parties. 

The BJP, which initially seemed to welcome the order changed its mind a day later and claimed that the order did not provide clarity on many issues and that there would be an overlap in the roles of the Election Commission and CIC. The Communist Party of India (Marxist) also termed the order as unacceptable. The Janata Dal (United) said that it was “totally opposed” to the move. 

During the hearings, the Communist Party of India (CPI) was the only party which had welcomed transparency in the funding of political parties. But even the CPI began speaking with a forked tongue after the CIC passed the order. Its National Secretary Mr.D.Raja described the order as “disputable”. One thing is clear from the reactions of the political class to the order – they will all gang-up and do everything in their power to prevent the public from knowing how much funds they raise and where they get their funds from. Are they justified in practicing such opacity? The Congress General Secretary, Mr.Janardhan Dwivedi claims that the CIC order will affect the privacy of political parties. The full implication of this statement will sink in when you realise that the source of 80 per cent of the funds obtained by political parties is dubious and not disclosed by them to the Election Commission. 

The Non-Response of Political Parties 

The issue was first raised by Mr.Anil Bairwal of the Association of Democratic Rights (ADR). He filed an RTI application in October, 2010 and sought information from six political parties – the Congress, the BJP, the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), the CPI, the CPI (M) and the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) which are classified as national by the Election Commission. He asked them to furnish the sources of the ten maximum voluntary contributions received by them between 2004-05 and 2009-10 and the mode of payment. He also sought the names and addresses of voluntary donors who had contributed more than Rs one lakh during this period. The Congress Party declined information and said it did not come under the purview of the RTI. The NCP said it did not have the staff to respond to such “unusual” queries. The BJP, BSP and CPI (M) did not respond. The CPI was the only party which furnished information on the top ten donors. Mr.S.C.Agrawal filed another RTI application with the Congress Party and the Bharatiya Janata Party in May, 2011 and sought information on promises made in their manifestoes, promises fulfilled, list of donors to these parties and mode of payment and whether party legislators have to compulsorily contribute to the party fund. Both the parties declined to respond to the queries on the ground that they were outside the purview of the RTI. 

The RTI applicants then filed complaints before the Central Information Commission and sought a direction to the political parties to disclose the information they had asked for as all these parties were “public authorities” and came within the ambit of Section 2(h) of the RTI Act and therefore, they were mandated to disclose full information. In view of complexity of the issues raised, the Chief Information Commissioner constituted a full bench of the Commission comprising Mr.Satyananda Mishra, Chief Information Commissioner; Ms.Annapurna Dixit and Mr.M.L. Sharma, Information Commissioners, to hear these petitions. 

The petitioners argued that political parties were “public authorities” as stipulated in the RTI Act because of the following reasons: They had constitutional status under the Tenth Schedule; they had the power to disqualify legislators from Parliament and state assemblies and bind legislators to party positions and voting inside legislative chambers; and they had statutory powers under the Representation of People Act, 1951; they made and un-made governments at the Centre and in the states. Further, there were other strong reasons as well. They were “substantially financed” by the government in multiple ways including allocation of land and buildings at concessional rates; income tax exemption on all the monies they collect; free air time on All India Radio and Doordarshan; and two free copies of electoral rolls for every constituency. All these subsidies clearly turned political parties into entities which were “substantially financed” by the government. Once this was established, they would automatically come within the ambit of the RTI. 

Mr.Bairwal showed how “transparent” political parties were at the moment. He said all political parties claim to work for the people and in the national interest. But the Income Tax returns of political parties obtained by his organization using the RTI Act revealed that on an average only about 20 per cent of the income of political parties came from donations that they disclose to the Election Commission under the Representation of People Act. “The sources of the remaining 80 per cent of the income are shrouded in mystery. This is what gives rise to all kinds of speculation about the pernicious influence of illegal money”. 

Political Parties Are “Substantially Funded” by the Government 

Since bodies or institutions which are “substantially financed by the government” come within the ambit of the RTI Act, the petitioners produced clinching evidence to establish this fact. Anil Bairwal presented tables showing benefits obtained by the six national parties under various heads. He showed that for three years from 2006-07, the Congress Party had availed of income tax exemption of Rs 300 crores whereas the BJP had availed exemption of Rs 141 crores. The BSP had got tax exemption of close to Rs 40 crores and the CPI(M) of Rs 18 crores. The cost of the air time given by All India Radio to the six national parties was Rs 28.56 lakhs during the Lok Sabha election in 2009 whereas the cost of the time allotted to these parties by Doordarshan during that election was Rs 10.75 crores. 

But the real “funding” of political parties by government comes via the real estate route. In the New Delhi area dozens of bungalows are rented out to political parties like 24, Akbar Road and 11, Ashoka Road, the headquarters of the Congress and the BJP. All major parties have similar allotments of rental accommodation. All these bungalows are given at ridiculously low rent to these parties. However, the real estate in the possession of political parties does not end here. Apart from these bungalows, the government, at various times, has allocated prime plots in Lutyen’s Delhi to political parties at throwaway prices. Mr.Bairwal calculated the current market value of these valuable plots of land as follows: the Congress Party - Rs 1036 crores; BJP – Rs 557 crores; CPI(M) – Rs 241crores; CPI – Rs 78 crores; Rashtriya Janata Dal – Rs123 crores, Samajwadi Party -261 crores; JD(U) – Rs129 crores. The total current value of plots allotted to political parties by the government in Delhi is Rs 2556 crores.

Finally, Mr.Bairwal argued that there was need for accountability and transparency in the functioning of the political parties and this had been emphasized by the Law Commission of India in its 170th Report on Reform of Electoral Law. The commission had said: “On the parity of the above reasoning, it must be said that if democracy and accountability constitute the core of our constitutional system, the same concepts must also apply to and bind the Political Parties which are integral to parliamentary democracy. It is the Political Parties that form the Government, man the Parliament and run the governance of the country. It is therefore, necessary to introduce internal democracy, financial transparency and accountability in the working of the Political Parties. A political party which does not respect democratic principles in its internal working cannot be expected to respect those principles in the governance of the country. It cannot be dictatorship internally and democratic in its functioning outside”.

In view of the arguments advanced by the complainants, the commission wrote to all the national political parties to elicit their views on the issues raised. How much respect our political parties have for national institutions and institutions created by law by parliament can be gauged from the fact that all the main parties ignored the letter sent by the commission. They neither had the courtesy nor the gumption to respond to the CIC’s queries. 

After hearing the parties, the CIC listed the following legal and constitutional facts, which it said, clearly emerged from the evidence at hand: That the political parties are the building blocks of a constitutional democracy; that under Tenth Schedule of the Constitution, a political party can have a Member of the House disqualified in certain circumstances; that a political party is required to be registered by the Election Commission of India under section 29A of the Representation of People Act, 1951; that under section 29C of the RP Act, 1951, a political party is required to submit a report for each Financial Year to the Election Commission of India in respect of contributions received by it in excess of 20,000/- rupees from any person as also contributions in excess of 20,000/- rupees received from non-Government companies; that in exercise of its powers under Article 324 read with section 29A of the RP Act, 1951 , and rules 5 & 10 of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961, the Election Commission has issued Election Symbols(Reservation & Allotment) Order, 1968, under which election symbols are allotted to various National/State political parties; that Election Commission can suspend or withdraw recognition of a recognized political party in the event of violation of provisions of Election Symbol (Reservation & Allotment) Order, 1968; that Central Information Commission’s order dated 29.4.2008 directing the Political Parties to disclose their Income Tax Returns holds the field and is being complied with.

On the financial side, the following facts had to be taken note of:

(a) that the Land & Development Office of the Ministry of Urban Development has allotted large tracts of land in Delhi to various political parties either free of cost or at concessional rates;

(b) that the Directorate of Estates, Ministry of Urban Development, has allotted accommodation in Delhi to various political parties on rental basis at concessional rates;

(c) that political parties have been claiming and granted total tax exemption under section 13A of the Income Tax Act for all their income;

(d) that the State has been indirectly financing political parties by way of free air time on All India Radio and Doordarshan of India during the elections; &

(e) that recognized political parties are issued copies of electoral rolls by the Election Commission, free of cost at the time of elections.

CIC Says Land Allotted to Political Parties at “Hugely Concessional Rates”

The commission dwelt on the real estate gifted to political parties by the government and said that even allowing for a margin of error in the estimation of the value of land allotted to various political parties by Mr.Bairwal, “we have reasons to believe that this land has been allotted at hugely concessional rates. The lease value of these properties in the open market has not been placed before us. Even so, we strongly believe that the premium and the lease rent being charged from the political parties does not reflect the true value of these properties. This, in our considered opinion, amounts to indirect financing and when added to the income tax exemption enjoyed by these political parties, it would amount to substantial financing”. Further, the Commission said that the complainants have provided information in regard to the lands allotted in Delhi by the central government. “We are informed that such allotments have also been made at the state capitals by the state governments. If so, this only reinforces the complainants’ contention that the appropriate governments have indirectly financed political parties in a big way”.

The commission said thirty per cent of their income which these political parties would have otherwise paid by way of income tax has been given up buy the government. This too amounted to “substantial financing, though indirectly” of political parties by the government. Added to this was the concessional allotment of land and buildings in prime locations in the national capital and probably in several state headquarters, if not at the district level also and with this the total amount of direct and indirect financing/funding of these political parties became “considerable”. The free air time on All India Radio and Doordharshan had to be added to this list, the commission said. “In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that central government has contributed significantly to the indirect financing of Political Parties in-question”.

In view of the above, the CIC concluded that the six national political parties fell into the category of “public authority” as defined in section 2(h) of the RTI. 

It said that “the preamble to the Constitution of India aims at securing to all its citizens: JUSTICE, social, economic and political; LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; and, EQUALITY of status and of opportunity. Coincidentally, the preamble of RTI Act also aims to promote these principles in the form of transparency and accountability in the working of the every public authority. It also aims to create an ‘informed citizenry’ and to contain corruption and to hold government and their instrumentalities accountable to the governed. Needless to say, political parties are important political institutions and can play a critical role in heralding transparency in public life. Political parties continuously perform public functions which define parameters of governance and socio-economic development in the country”. Therefore, they came within the ambit of the RTI Act. 

The CIC noted that the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution had recommended that political parties as well as individual candidates be made subject to a proper statutory audit of the amounts they spend. In Common Cause Vs. Union of India (AIR 1996 SC 3081), the Supreme Court has dealt with the income and expenditure incurred by the political parties and has laid emphasis on transparency on election funding. The Commission said “The people of India must know the source of expenditure incurred by political parties and by the candidates in the process of election. These judicial pronouncements unmistakably commend progressively higher level of transparency in the functioning of political parties in general and their funding in particular”. 

In view of the above, the CIC upheld the contention of the petitioners and said that the Congress Party, BJP, CPI(M), CPI, NCP and BSP have been substantially financed by the central government under section 2(h)(ii) of the RTI Act. “The criticality of the role being played by these political parties in our democratic set up and the nature of duties performed by them also point towards their public character, bringing them in the ambit of section 2(h). The constitutional and legal provisions discussed herein above also point towards their character as public authorities”, the Commission said.